Sunday, May 1, 2016

Mass Murderer Bertha Gifford

I wrote briefly about Bertha Gifford on this blog a few years ago, but since I've included her in my latest book, Wicked Women of Missouri, I'm going to write about her again, this time a little more extensively. What follows is condensed from a chapter in the book.
Twenty-two-year-old Bertha Williams was said to be one of the prettiest girls in Jefferson County, Missouri, when Henry Graham married her in 1894. Ten years later, though, their marriage hit the rocks. According to later rumors, Henry started carrying on with another woman, but Bertha, still a beautiful woman, wasted little time pining over her husband’s infidelity. Instead, she started spending time with Eugene Gifford, a young man ten years her junior, and he fell under her spell and broke off his engagement to another young woman.
The Graham marital drama came to an abrupt halt when Henry suddenly took sick and died of pneumonia. Then, in 1907, after a respectable mourning period, Bertha married Gene Gifford, and the couple moved to Catawissa in neighboring Franklin County, just far enough away to escape the gossip of Morse Mill.
Gifford became a successful farmer in the Big Bend area north of Catawissa, and Bertha, who fed the hired hands, became noted for her cooking. She also cared for her neighbors whenever they took sick and soon gained a reputation as a respected country nurse.
From 1912 through the early 1920s, a number of her patients, including several children, died from unknown causes, but few people, if any, thought the deaths suspicious. That changed though, when seven-year-old Lloyd Schamel and his six-year-old brother, Elmer, died within six weeks of each other in 1925 while under Bertha’s care. The deaths aroused the suspicions of Dr. W.H. Hemker, who was summoned in both cases when the boys were already beyond help. He recommended an autopsy after Elmer died, but the boy’s father did not agree to the procedure. Deciding not to press the issue, Dr. Hemker wrote “acute unknown disease” and “acute gastritis” on Elmer’s death certificate, wording similar to what he had written on the death certificates of several of Bertha’s previous patients.
After the Schamel boys’ deaths, Bertha’s neighbors started whispering about possible foul play, and some even wrote anonymous letters to Franklin County prosecuting attorney Frank Jenny urging an investigation, but no official action was taken. Then in May of 1927, yet another of Bertha’s patients, forty-nine-year-old Ed Brinley, died at her home under mysterious circumstances. The death renewed Dr. Hemker’s suspicions, but he and a second doctor, whom Hemker had called in on the case, could not agree on a cause of death. Hemker again ended up writing “acute unknown disease” and “acute gastritis” on the death certificate.
After Brinley’s death, though, the tongues of Catawissa started wagging again, and the prosecutor received more letters urging an investigation. A St. Louis newspaperman arrived on the scene and, after talking to people around Catawissa, wrote a story naming at least five people who had died mysteriously while under Bertha Gifford’s care. In November of 1927, the prosecutor finally ordered a grand jury to look into Brinley’s death. Bertha reportedly “scared off the investigation” by threatening libel suits against anyone who testified against her, and the jury failed to indict her.
Not long afterward, Bertha and Gene moved to neighboring St. Louis County, but her former neighbors kept up the pressure on Prosecutor Jenny, who summoned another grand jury in August of 1928. After hearing testimony that Bertha Gifford had often purchased arsenic at a Pacific drugstore, several times just prior to the death of one of her patients, the jury indicted her for first degree murder in the poisoning deaths of Elmer Schamel and Ed Brinley. A charge of murdering Lloyd Schamel was later added to the indictment, and during the subsequent investigation, Bertha was implicated in at least seventeen deaths going all the way back to her first husband. She was charged only for the last three deaths, though, and she was tried only in the case of Ed Brinley. In November 1928, a Franklin County Circuit Court jury found her not guilty by reason of insanity, and she was committed to the State Hospital at Farmington the following month. She died there in 1951.

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Just beginning to delve into the mystic of Bertha and have a few questions. Where did the insanity plea directly come from? Did the jury recommend it? Or did the court instill it? At the trail were any doctors present to testify to the sanity/mind set of Bertha? Was her son, James,in attendance? As Marc Houseman, director of The Washington Historical Society, pointed out, perhaps Eugene, and whatever mental notions he may have suppressed remain a mystery. In scrutinizing the time frame of deaths under Bertha's bedside manners I believe this. The passing of Eugene's mother and brother in 1912 and 1913, followed in 1915 by the three Stuhlfelder children deaths and then the death of her first husband, Henry, in 1916 my have triggered her complete vindictive rampage. Did Bertha rush to her ex husband's bedside? She was clever and applied meticulous timing. What of those- if any- that survived the night when Bertha came to comfort their ailing conditions? I've stumbled upon a reference to magazine entitled TRUE, from 1981,which did a 9 page retrospective article on the trail--Do you have any knowledge of such an article? Bertha's great grand daughter's book and a handful of web based pages provide a lure something close to that of the Titanic- with so many tributaries to explore. It's only been a few generations, yet living relatively close by, the hideous
incidentals still resonate with locals when one merely mentions Bertha Gifford. I would appreciate any comments or enlightening info you may have.

Unknown said...

1

Larry Wood said...

As you suggest, Unknown, this case still has a lot of question marks, and I'm not sure I can answer the specific questions you've asked--at least not all of them. I do know that Bertha's lawyers were the ones who suggested and pursued the insanity defense after first failing to get her confession (or testimony about it) thrown out. Several expert witnesses (i.e. doctors) testified as to her insanity, as did several acquaintances, and even Gene, her husband, testified that she was nervous and excitable. Even the state's expert witnesses (alienists or what we would call psychiatrists today), although called to help make the case against her, tended to reinforce the idea that she was insane. Yes, I have read the 1981 magazine article.

Bloody Benders Again

I've written on this blog about the Bloody Benders of southeast Kansas at least once before, maybe more than once, but I recently finish...